A Student Question on Saya and Yang.

Dear All

Here are explanations for a question on differences of saya and contextual meanings of yang:

Based on Itu radio saya in the lecture.

 

Itu (that)

Radio = radio

Saya = I or me

 

Hence the lecture example = that my radio i.e. that is my radio.

The possessive order as explained is in opposite construction. And Malay does not need a is or are or am.

 

More examples based on lecture content:

 

Ini kawan saya

This is my friend

 

Di situ sekolah saya

There is my school

 

Siapa guru saya?

Who is my teacher?

 

Mengapa hari ini?

Why this day => Why today?

 

Di mana teman lelaki saya

Where is my boy friend?

 

Yang mana kawan perempuan saya

Which one is my female partner?

 

Yang = emphasis marker

Different meanings of yang is contextually dependent:

 

1.       Emphatic reference: Yang ini siapa?  = Who is this?

2.       Emphasis:  Saya suka yang itu.  = I like that one

3.       Elaboration: Saya tidak suka hari yang panas. = I don’t like days that are hot.

 

Notice that yang may be deleted which also removes the emphasis

 

1a. Ini siapa? Who is this?

2.a. Saya suka itu. I like that.

3a. Saya tidak suka hari panas. I dislike hot days.

Terima kasih

cikgu

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s